What is Citizenship Amendment Act and Why is NRC a matter of concern.


The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) led National Democratic Alliance won the election with a thumping majority held on May, 2019 this year. In the same year the central government has introduced several bills such as Transgender persons (protection of rights) bill and Jammu and Kashmir Re-organisation bill in the parliament. In this same series the government introduced Citizenship Amendment bill and it became an act on Dec 12, 2019.
Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016

Earlier in 2016, the BJP government introduced the same bill in Lok Sabha. However due to lack of majority in Rajya Sabha the bill got lapsed. But over these years several regional parties like ADMK, TRS, YSRC, BJD and Janata Dal started to give their support to NDA. Since then, BJP government has managed to pass all their long-pending bills in the Rajya Sabha.


Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019

The Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 aims not to treat any person belonging to Buddhist, Christian, Hindu, Jain, Parsi or Sikh community from three neighbouring Islam states Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan on or before the 31st of December, 2014 as illegal immigrants and also the aggregate period of residence or service in government is reduced to 5 years from 11 years originally. However, the Act had not included the Muslims from those neighbouring countries and this has lead to severe criticism. But actually, the real reason for the strong protest is implementation of another draconian National Register of Citizens.

                                               

National Register of Citizens

The Citizenship Amendment Act, 1955 mandates compulsory register of every citizen of India and issue national identity card by the central government. Except Assam, it is proposed to come into effect in 2021. The central government may require the citizens to prove citizenship by submitting any of the documents prescribed. However, the document doesn’t include Aadhar, Voter ID or Passport.


Why is NRC a matter of concern?

The NRC has been so far implemented only in Assam. In 2014, certain organisation from Assam filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court (SC) seeking deportation of illegal immigrants who entered Assam from Bangladesh on or before 1971. Following this SC has ordered the central government to update NRC in accordance with citizenship statute. Over 19 lakh applicants name was found missing in the final list released by the government in 2015. After several protest, the central government has agreed to update the list. Still, after the second update, four lakhs people name including the family members of the former president of India, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and a retired Army soldier, etc. were missing in the final list. Several persons including members from BJP have challenged the updated final list before the Supreme Court. Several people blamed that implementing authorities were not cautious and that has resulted in a lot of confusion and uncertainty.
 The government has now proposed to implement the NRC across the country. Many persons have challenged the constitutional validity of the Citizenship Amendment Act and the implementation of NRC on the ground of discrimination in the Supreme Court. It can’t be denied that the implementation of NRC has several challenges.  Any procedure that ought to be implemented should be without any room for injustice, unambiguous and should be clear, just and fair to the people.



(Views expressed in this article is personal)


For any queries regarding the article contact

K.Vasanth (Final year L.L.B Hons, School of Excellence in Law, Tamil Nadu Dr Ambedkar law university)

Mail: vasanthtnau@gmail.com
-

Comments

K.G.Raam said…
Congrats for ur writing 👏👏👏but the matter is 'Sub-Judice' so i can't comment on the content...best wishes
December 28, 2019 at 12:40 PM
Post a Comment

Other blog Posts

The happiness when you own a thing !

Image
image credit  Mridhu.B.R We at present are living in a globalized world, just call it a global village. Here our tastes and preferences are not ours anymore, it is controlled by external factors that surround us. We are influenced in a wider range by various entities which choose things for us and we get very little chance to choose the right product based on our needs. Consider a girl who plans to buy a lipstick (be it any other cosmetic products that she uses). Why does she need it?  she may have various reasons to buy a lipstick like a perception that she might look good in it, want it since most woman use lipsticks, saw that in an advertisement so she responds to get it, saw a movie and was inspired from her favourite actress who looks great on lipstick so decides to get one for her, or maybe she thinks that the society has fixed using lipstick as an ideal yardstick of looking beautiful. The above are the possibilities that she would buy the lipstick. Now the...
Read more

THE "ARRIBADA"

Image
image credit @Ashika One can never imagine the secrets hidden by nature underwater. Deep-sea divers, marine experts are few among the luckiest to unravel the ascetic value of the oceans to us. The oceans of the world sustain millions of species from tiny algae to the largest mammal ‘the blue whale’. One such species which is found in the tropical regions of the oceans has its presence over 100 million years! Believed to live more than fifty years, it swims across the ocean thousands of miles with its four flipper legs and bears a protective shield (top shell) called carapace all along in its entire journey. They have olive coloured body parts and thus named as ‘The Olive Ridley’ turtles. Olive Ridley turtles are the second smallest next to the Kemp Ridley’s and the most abundant of all sea turtles found in the world. The females are larger than males. They prey on jellyfish, crustaceans and snails. The olive ridley is listed as vulnerable under the International Union for C...
Read more

Toll Free Traveller

Image
“Their bicycles caused no little astonishment on the way, and the remarks passed by the natives were almost amusing. At some of the villages the boys clustered round the machines, and where they could, caught hold of them and ran behind until they were tired out. Many enquiries were made as to the name of ‘them queer horses,’ some called them ‘whirligigs’, ‘menageries’ and ‘valparaisons’. Between Wolver Hampton and Birmingham, attempts were made to upset the riders by throwing stones.”             Above is the newspaper report about three riders who set off from Liverpool to London, a journey of three days and so more resemblant to modern motor cycle touring on March 1869. The  passion for motorcycle touring around the world started in the late 19 th century. More than a century now, motorcycle riders have grown in large numbers all around the world and Indi...
Read more

The Novel C O R O N A

Image
  -  ZAKIR HUSSAIN.P "As humans, we like to think we're in charge of our corner of the universe.   But now and then a microscopic entity reminds us that we are not."              -Neil DeGrasse Tyson A novel virus refers to a virus not seen before. It can be a virus that is isolated from its natural reservoir or isolated as the result of spread to an animal or human host where the virus had not been identified before. Due to such characters, the Coronavirus causing COVID-19 disease has made the entire human population vulnerable. Governments across the world have blocked their entire borders and have set up quarantine facilities. The novel coronavirus on the date has caused more than 15,000 deaths all over the world. There is also a steady increase in positive cases each day. The elderly, children and poor are more prone to the virus than anybody else. India is no exception and the country has already recorde...
Read more

Diet: The double edged sword

Image
SARS-Corona virus diseased and deceased numbers have reached more than 82,000 across the globe. Discussing about pathogen, carrier or mode of transmission, Symptoms, treatment, precaution and control measures has been extensively analyzed in almost all media. Despite it, some information regarding mode of transformation and treatment are seems ambiguous. Health care professional’s claim virus was initially transmitted from under cooked meat. Similarly, few have been treated with symptomatic treatment and cured successfully due to well receptive immune system. In both these scenario, the importance of diet in physical well being is highlighted. On the similar note, Our Honorable front line workers, Prime Minister, Chief ministers of respective state government, Union and state ministries, secretaries and importantly most of the people functions responsibly towards containment of disease and prevents loss of lives. But few politicians, public are indulging in irresponsible activ...
Read more

My Suicidal Note

Image
Hi to all, I refer myself as Prince lonely toad . My father used to call me Mr.Toad and my mother named me as Little prince frogger. We are a wanderer and I belong to a large family with 12 siblings. I am the youngest kiddo of all. My family often worries about my future because of my physical dissimilarities with other members. Yes, I am a differently-abled spirit with one functional leg and an eye. I never thought that life would be so difficult until that day. The day and the events pushed me to take this extreme step. Now, I am giving up my hope of living. Yes, this is my suicide note and I am about to quit. In general suicide note will punish the accused listed in it, but like a frog (As a relief measure to all my fellow readers, I am just a frog but not a human being), I am so powerless to punish those accused. Besides these all, I wrote this letter to feel u all guilt and make my death reasonable to all vulnerable powerless section. Causes of death and accused are listed in t...
Read more

'Positivity is all what we need'

Image
                                Image credit @Ashika                      My short insight on  positive attitude  I have seen many people struggle to step forward in their life. People do not suffer since they run out of money or they pertain to a particular caste or religion. Lack of positivism is the sole reason behind almost all sufferings. We take care of our body with physical exercise so as, mental health must also be trained to gain positive attitude. This positivity has helped me support my family and friends in different ways. When you are positive you keep your surrounding in the same manner. You attract positive things more and persons with such positive attitude get attracted to you. Everybody tend to follow a certain religion, we may name it differently but the ultimate thing which gives us deep insight on wh...
Read more

“Imaginable Immortality”

Image
Immortality described as unending existence which has been proclaimed to be attained through mentally, spiritually or physically. Though the belief system of immortality has been quite common and familiar across the horizontal and vertical dimension of geographical territory and human historical timescale, there is no proof or material evidence available yet. Despite these counter arguments prevailing in the rational society, I would try my level best to convince my fellow readers about “Imaginable (Possible) Immortality” in the real world through this article.  Immortality as described above may sound more of spiritual, but in reality immortality as an end can be reached through the means, of spiritual as well as scientific. Personally, I would prefer to approach eternal through spiritual means but due to societal pressure where spirituality is attached to religion and also described as “Non-Sense”, I better start with science. YES, I BECOME RATIONAL NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
Read more

Being Indian

Image
We all have sung National Anthem. Most of us would have first started singing the anthem in our schools. Not even a day started without singing the national anthem during our school days. When I entered college I was shocked, no such activity was carried out there. The class started at eight in the morning and nothing else was so special. What I missed in my college were the morning prayers which ended up singing the national anthem which became a regular practice of my schooling. In spite of our diversities, we all stand together to sing the anthem. It makes us feel the power of ‘we’. The National Anthem was first sung in the congress session of Calcutta during 1911. So why was the anthem written by Rabindranath Tagore? Is that all the countries have an anthem so India should also have one? No, the national anthem written by Rabindranath Tagore is another expression of the unity of India. Songs and symbols that emerged during the freedom struggle serve as a constant reminde...
Read more

The Mystery of Pride

Image
Human beings are amazing creatures on earth, because of the influential nature that humans posses, we tend to impact and bring change in nature. The change sometimes is positive or negative. Billions now are threatened from a deadly disease called COVID 19 caused by a virus named ‘Corona’ and still we could control the situation following various ways like social distancing, lockdown, wearing mask etc. We feel proud of ourselves for the scientific development the human has attained so far and soon hope science to produce a vaccine for this deadly disease. We are proud of this nature of humans and with pride , we hope for the best in the coming months. What is pride? According to the Oxford dictionary, “Pride a feeling of pleasure or satisfaction that you get when you or people who are connected with you have done something well or own something that other people admire”. Overall what pride gives us is a feeling of pleasure. Pride is also a belief that one is superior to ...
Read more